The best breast pumps, from electric to manual models

ThisMedischBreast pumps have come to a reasonable distance because of the original patent filed in 1898 by J.H. Hoover for a breast pump meant for people, not cows. Almost 100 years later, in 1991, Medela marketed their first consumer-targeted pumps. Right here, we stand 30 years later with infinite choices, but none of which might be excellent.

The search for the right pump in your physique and state of affairs will be attempting. However, whether or not it is a lengthy Tuesday at work or an uncommon kid-free evening out, you’ll be able to dwell without one. I sit right here pumping while I write this very article, hoping to eke out sufficient ounces for my 6-month-old son.

As a mom of 4 nurslings, I’ve examined and tried just about every pump available on the market within the pursuit of a quiet, mild unicorn that can produce probably the most milk doable. Sadly, I am right here to say it simply does not exist; however, of the 13 fashions I examined for this information, a couple of coming shut. 

To assist slim down our suggestions, I additionally interviewed three lactation specialists and an OB-GYN. As a result of pumping is as distinctive as the numerous bodies on the earth, it is essential to notice that what works most OK for another person may not work most acceptable for you. Most significantly, all of our specialists mentioned thinking about your particular wants for a breast pump before you purchase. 

Greatest wearable breast pump

The best breast pumps, from electric to manual models

The Elvie is hands-free, leakproof, and looks like a progressive pump of the longer term.

  • Pros: Palms-free, positioned instantly into your bra; leakproof; simple pairing with a helpful app
  • Cons: Lights will be seen by the shirt, which is not discreet; increased studying curve than conventional pumps to assemble and use; decreased visibility

Elvie makes the very best wearable pump available on the market, and it’s a must-have for individuals who haven’t got the chance to cease and pump. The Elvie Pump is principally leakproof should you observe the instructions compared to the competitors.

The Willow, its essential competitor, brought on me loads of tears and spilled milk. I spoke with my very own lactation guide Gillian Foreman, IBCLC, of Modern Breastfeeding and Education, about this. She explains that that results from Willow’s “flip to complete,” a counterintuitive step. As an alternative, Elvie’s pouring system lets you dump the milk, which is saved properly within the pump, right into a bottle.

The Elvie additionally has a novel storage system. You do not have to pour something in any respect; however, you can separate the milk compartments and retail them shortly and simply. Nevertheless, I discovered that water tends to get caught throughout the washing and drying course.

There are a couple of sacrifices to picking this pump over double electrical. The most important for me was output. I made much less milk with the Elvie than a standard pump; however, I made extra milk versus the Willow. I attribute this to its mild but efficient suction that felt much less like nips and extra like a child’s mouth. Foreman provides that most purchasers see half of the standard output with wearable pumps. 

She additionally brings up one other frequent concern with the Elvie pump. “It’s important to know what flange dimension you might be. You may [use inserts] for smaller nipples; however, you cannot make it larger,” she mentioned. “The most important criticism I’ve seen is whether or not [the nipple] is within the center, [and if not] there will be ache as a result of it is likely to be rubbing.” With follow, rubbing wasn’t an issue for me, and I finally achieved a snug pumping expertise, however not essentially for a full bottle every day. 

The pump cannot be utterly discreet. My 7-year-old calls the Elvie pumps “bionic boobs,” He isn’t incorrect — the lights are present by clothes.

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

Greatest handbook breast pump

The best breast pumps, from electric to manual models

The Haakaa attaches to your breast, hands-free, offering a low-level suction while you are doing one thing else, like nura se on the opposite facet. 

  • Pros: Palms-free, fixed low-level suction relatively than pulling like with a standard hand pump
  • Cons: Can get barely painful or irritating, excessive spill danger

Conventional handbook pumps use a one-handed pumping system, where you squeeze a deal related to the flange and pump to extract milk from the breast. The issue is that about ten pumps in your hand are already drained. Haakaa appears to have solved this drawback with a hands-free system that gives low-level suction. 

The pump catches milk that will be wasted if you’re, say, feeding your child on the opposite breast, whereas additionally pumping some milk. It isn’t a complete substitute for an electrical pump, although. As an alternative, it completely suits the invoice as a second pump for occasional use to alleviate strain when you’re overfull, particularly amid the evening when the newborn is just up for nursing on one facet.

LaShanda Dandrich, director of facilitators and board-licensed lactation guide (IBCLC) with Chocolate Milk Cafe National, says there is a probably dangerous false impression that folks want to make use of it regularly. “The Haakaa is normally beneficial for households which have an oversupply and the newborn feeds, and is happy, and latches nice; however, the breast nonetheless feels full after the feed,” she says. She warns that overusing it may create an oversupply, as you might be instructing the breast that extra milk is required. “Simply use the Haakaa till the breast feels somewhat softer,” she recommends.

The lovely silicone flower stopper serves as a leak-prevention plug, and it does its job effectively. Nonetheless, this product has an excessive spill danger because it may simply be kicked off by your nursing toddler or can detach periodically if the suction is not sealed. However, regardless of a couple of spills, I could not dwell with out them.

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

Greatest moveable breast pump

The best breast pumps, from electric to manual models

An on-the-go various to a full-size pump, the Motif Luna Double Electric Pump is a slight, quiet, and straightforward possibility with severe milk output.

  • Pros: Small and moveable, excessive milk output, sturdy motor/suction, quiet, simple meeting and cleansing
  • Cons: Exhausting plastic flanges

Should you plan to purchase, only one pump and your child is solely breastfeeding, each ounce issues. That is why the Motif Luna made the reduce, with one of many highest outputs of the pumps we examined. Should you remove all different elements quickly, as you want the best output in your cash, that is the most straightforward and economical selection. 

Moveable pumps, more minor because they may simply be than conventional double electrical pumps, have gotten a nasty rap for being weak and disappointing, with motors that do not make final by some kids’ nursing wants. “However this one, we have seen higher outcomes, and [most] insurances now supply it,” Fandrich says. “Individuals prefer it, and after I work with individuals who have it, they’ve been getting good output.”

You will be sure you might be selecting an excellent pump if the motor is powerful however does not essentially really feel sturdy on the breasts, Dandrich explains, and the Luna suits this description. Foreman calls the pump spectacular and cautions that folks ought to select the upper-grade Luna, not the decrease grade Duo, saying there’s a dramatic distinction.

The Luna has several components together with the connectors, valves, and flanges, and they’re all simply manageable, easy to handwash, and intuitive to reassemble. I significantly love the three ranges of LED lighting on the pump for evening use, prominent buttons that do not require a glance again on the handbook, and a timer exhibiting what number of minutes you’ve got been pumping. It is a quiet pump if you seek to pump discreetly at work or on the go.

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

Most excellent double electrical breast pump

The best breast pumps, from electric to manual models

The Spectra S1 Plus Electric Breast Pump is a real workhorse, options excessive output and a powerful, lasting motor.

  • Pros: Extraordinarily comfy, reasonably priced, excessive output, sturdy, motor and excessive setting capabilities, remembers your settings for the subsequent session, has a deal with easy transport.
  • Cons: Shuts off after some time, so you will want to begin over to proceed

If I had ever to love a pump, my one real love is the Spectra S1. It has the best output of all of the moveable pumps, and it does not die after you’ve got had one and even two extra youngsters.

Jennifer Hoverboard-licensed censed lactation guide (IBCLC) with The Lactation Network recommends Spectra with its closed system for hygiene causes, which means milk circulates by a hygienic route away from the pump mechanically likes the adjustable settings for controlling suction ranges and the letdown versus expression modes.

With solely this pump, I expertise a second “letdown” or wave of milk midway by pumping, which provides the following output. Because of the sturdy motor and a feel, the majority mimics my child’s nursing patterns. “It’s strange hospitality-grade grade,'” Horne says. “It performs quietly and has a handy evening mild for nighttime pumping.”

I choose where I am not utilizing is the best or lowest setting, so I’ve some capability to alter it if I want it to be somewhat stronger or weaker that day. The Spectra S1 suits that requirement — its ranges go as much as 12, whereas I frolicked within the four to five vary more often than not. I want the buttons mentioned “stimulation” and “expression” versus wave symbols; however, except for this control buttons, timer, and setting person-pleasant peasant.

I want to see Spectra make a softer rimmed flange, much like Medela’s Personal Fit Flex technology that incorporates a rubber ring as an alternative to laborious plastic. Thicausey makes the Spectra the last word pump.

Like the Motif, the Specters have identical conventional pump components that might be simple to scrub, but collectively, and troubleshoot. Whereas this pump is much like its competitor, Medela Pump in Style, Medisch is nearly universally supplied by insurance coverage. The Medela did not provide a timer or time log. YouMedisch may improve the pace, solely the suction.

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

Greatest hospital-grade breast pump

The best breast pumps, from electric to manual models

Our specialists say that renting a hospital-grade Medela Symphony is likely valued value This severe output.

  • Pros: Robust however mild suction, excessive output
  • Cons: Costly to buy, renting is usually a problem, not moveable, not many, bells and whistles by way of settings

The one perk of being caught in a hospital with a sick new child was assembly the Medela Symphony. Advisable by our specialists as the very best hospital-grade pump, this product is the holy grail of pumps. The everyday shopper often accesses it by a rental program at your native hospital. 

Horne explains that hospital-grade pumps are multi-use mainly early designed to usher in and keep provided provide. “These pumps are sometimes beneficial within the hospital in case your child is untimely or having different breastfeeding difficulties early on,” she says. “They’re additionally beneficial if you’re solely pumping, had earlier breast surgical procedure, have situations which will affect milk provide, or are inducing lactation.”

As a skilled effect be most excited to see 50% extra milk than typical from one in all my shortest pumping periods ever. In nearly 10 minutes, n usually 20 to 25, I produced that additional milk, not any additional pressure or discomfort. Foreman credit the Symphony‘s piston motor system this pump makes use of, which she says is a unique sort from others.

There are cons to those programs, primarily that they need to be a plug, get in, and you need to undergo the pink tape of collaborating with insurance coverage to hire one until you might be keen to shell out hundreds of {dollars} to a personal one. One other drawback to Symphony is that there aren’t many customizable settings. However, some may discover this helpful — generally, too many buttons do not play well with only a few hours of sleep. I found it good to have “on,” “up simply,” and “letdown” buttons; however, others might want extra options.

Fandrich recommends the Symphony for many who have a low provide within the first few weeks of their child’s life and NICU dad and mom. Although you hopefully won’t ever want one, it is nice to know such an environment-friendly pump is accessible at many hospitals if you’re caught there in an emergency by yourself or along with your child.

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

Our breast pumps testing methodology. 

To remove variability in output, I examined every pump at a similar time daily and for an equal period, between 20 and 25 minutes. Under are the standards I used to gauge every pump:

  • Ease of meeting/studying curve: Nobody needs to have their breast milk let down, whereas they’re preventing getting a breast pump assembled and dealing. We seemed for pumps with clear instructions, easy-to-follow meeting directions, and manageable components. We opted for pumps that stroll you thru the steps, akin to Elvie’s video directions on their app, to make sure you are arranged for a good pumping session.
  • Milk output: They do not name it liquid gold for anything. Each drop issues when you’re attempting to save lots of up sufficient to get a date evening away from the newborn or simply enough to daycare to make it by the subsequent day. However, we valued increased output, not at the price of our following standards.
  • Consolation: A cushy pump does not feel prefer it’s injuring, chafing, nipping at, or in any other case hurting your nipples or breasts. Our specialists clarify that it also should not be sucking too vigorously and inflicting discomfort, as this has an additional impact on what you are attempting to realize. As an alternative, a powerful motor with a mild suction is beneficial. We additionally seemed for added consolation options akin to rubber lining across the flange.
  • Portability and different entry options: Pumps are getting extra handy by the yr, with most specializing in portability. However, other entry factors are essential, akin to the ability to time your pumping session, see this info in darkish and skim and perceive the buttons.
  • Cleansing and storing: We solely selected pumps that might be simple to scrub and retail, except these pesky valves, which come on many pumps and is usually a little harder to clean. Pumps which might be simple to put out to dry are helpful, so you’ll be able to simply handwash and stroll away, whereas others appear to carry water in annoying spots and require a full hand dry.

What else we have tried

What else do we suggest?

  • Medela Harmony Breastpump ($41.99): If the Haakaa is not your factor, and you might be searching for a standard hand pump, that is the very best one. Made with a highly comfy outer rubber ring, it makes you extra comfortable and lives as much as they declare that it provides you extra milk quicker. Whereas my hand did get drained, the pump produced a couple of ounces in simply a few minutes. 
  • Freemie cups (not the pump) (from $69.99): The Freemie assortment system gives cups that go in your bra, eliminating the necessity for bottles hanging down in the entrance of you and making for a discreet pumping system. Whereas we did not love the energy and output of the Freemie pump itself, we suggest wanting into these cups as a storage system, which may generally be hooked up to different forms of pumps with adapters from other manufacturers, relying on your setup. Consider it because of the budget-friendly approach to entry among the perks of the Elvie without spending lots of {dollars}.

What we do not suggest

  • Elvie Stride ($210): A less expensive various to the unique Elvie, this swing pump made extra milk than the Elvie; however, it lacked the comfort of its pricier wearable counterpart. It was somewhat clunkier to assemble, and the components are likely to be extra cumbersome to scrub with extra grooves and distinctive features. 
  • Lansinoh Smart Pump 2.0 Double Electric Breast Pump ($128.99), Freemie Liberty II Deluxe Breast Pump System ($149.99), and Evenflo Advanced Double Electric Breast Pump ($101.99): These moveable pumps did simply what Foreman mentioned they might do: underperformed. Decrease output was the primary concern because they did not have a sufficiently robust motor to go the space. 
  • Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump ($24.94): This single-side handbook pump led to at least one drained hand and little milk because the vary of the deal with did not present sufficient suction varies to extract milk correctly. I ended up utilizing two palms for what ought to solely take one to stabilize the pump and supply enough strain.
  • Medela Pump in Style with MaxFlow Breast Pump ($189.99): Corresponding to the Spectra S1, the Medela is a tried-and-true favorite that many individuals take pleasure in. However, for $50 extra and some much fewer choices, it did not maintain as much as the Spectra S1. In case you have a possibility between the Medela and different moveable pumps solely, it’ll nonetheless get the job completed.
  • Willow Wearable Breast Pump ($499.99): There is likely no hotter debate between pumping dad and mom between Willow and Elvie. The Willow can be utilized with storage luggage or containers, whereas the Elvie solely permits containers. The principal variations had been that the Elvie by no means leaked for me and was a lot gentler. Unlike the Willow, you should purchase a single Elvie pump relatively than a set of two. Each produced comparable output.

Breast pumps FAQs

Does insurance coverage line breast pumps?

Sure, many breast pumps are lined by insurance coverage, and legislation requires insurance coverage firms to cowl all breastfeeding-related companies at some point of breastfeeding, explains Dr. Betsy Greenleaf, DO, an obstetrician, and girls well being knowledgeable.

Foreman provides that you could be not but see insurers masking new hands-free pumps akin to Elvie, although some may offer the choice to pay for simply a part of one with an improved charge. Our decision, the Spectra S1 pump, is broadly lined by many insurers, as is the Medela Pump in Style.

Is pumping unhealthy in your breasts?

No, in truth, Greenleaf says that pumping and breastfeeding may lower the risk of breast cancer, particularly when you have breastfed for at the very least a yr. Generally, pumping can lead to breast damage with improper use, which around 15% of breastfeeders have experienced.

Foreman has seen accidents occur on account of overpumping. She says that individuals flip-up pumps, pondering that they will get extra output and create injury from pumping too excessive when painful. Ensure that you have the correct flange dimension or form to stop damage. Foreman says the nipple should not run in opposition to the cylinder or pull in an excessive amount of the areola.

Long run, pumping does not improve sagging or drooping within the breasts, which Foreman says is simply a part of hormonal modifications as you age. 

Is it OK to simply pump and never breastfeed?

Sure, that is known as “unique pumping.” Individuals might select to solely pump for numerous causes, together with feeling touched out, work or college conflicts, painful latching, and dysphoric milk ejection reflex (D-MER).

Foreman recommends discovering help teams online for unique pumpers as it may be a difficult journey. Special pumping takes extra time between pumping, cleansing components, storing milk, warming up bottles, and feeding the newborn.

If that is your route, Greenleaf says that you could make a bond nonetheless along with your child successfully. It will not impair your capability to take action, mainly because you are likely to be a bit extra well-rested when others help with feeding periods.

Does breast milk lose vitamins when pumped?

It is doable. Infants are extra environment-friendly at extracting the fatty “hindmilk” that pumping can generally inefficiently produce. Hindmilk is “a key ingredient for progress, hormone manufacturing, and mental growth,” Greenleaf says. Moreover, our pores and skin have microorganisms that may be probably transferred to the milk extra simply with pumping than breastfeeding, so she suggests following breastmilk handling guidelines. Lastly, Greenleaf says that point, refrigeration, and freezing can lower pumped milk’s microorganisms ThisMedischantioxidant, immune elements, and fats content material. 

You may also like


Latest articles


PROS Active noise cancellation is even better.Sound is more balanced...

Mobile Pixels Duex Lite Review

The Mobile Pixels Duex Lite ($269) differs from most...

Payoneer Review

Payoneer is a financial services firm based in New...

Disclosure: Written and researched by the Get Gear Tech crew. We spotlight services and products you may discover fascinating. If you happen to purchase them, we could get a small share of the income from the sale from our companions. We could obtain merchandise freed from cost from producers to test. This doesn't drive our resolution as to whether a product is featured or beneficial. We function independently from our promoting group. We welcome your suggestions. Please e-mail us at [email protected] 

Get Gear Tech is an affiliate-based website that tests and reviews the best tech, appliances, gear, and more. You can trust our veteran reviewers and experts to find the best stuff just for you. Get Gear Tech strives to be probably the most trusted product suggestion and service on the web. We obsessively test and report on thousands of things annually to suggest one of the best of all the things. We aim to save lots of you time and get rid of the stress of buying, whether or not you’re on the lookout for on a regular basis gear or items for family members. We work with complete editorial independence. Meaning nothing seems on the location as a suggestion until our writers and editors have deemed it one of the best by our rigorous reporting and testing.


find out more!