Wednesday, October 20, 2021

The 5 best kitchen knives we tested

Must read

There could also be no extra vital instrument in your kitchen other than your Chef’s knife. It’s the one-stop shop for your whole slicing, chopping, dicing, and trimming wants. Positive, different kitchen knives effectively value their metal; however, we will not stress this sufficient: if you are going to put your cash into anybody knife, or in the event, you’re contemplating shopping for a knife set, take into consideration a single, high-quality Chef’s knife to start.

Whereas we do supply a piece of information on the best knife sets — and suggest some budget-friendly choices just like the Victorinox Fibrox Professional set (a staple in lots of industrial kitchens) — you may find yourself with lots of filler items in the event you go the pre-packaged route. Everybody we have spoken with on the matter, from famed butcher Pat LaFrieda to late gourmand and Chef Anthony Bourdain, has been fast to the purpose: most knife units are a waste of cash. And having knocked round sufficient industrial bars and kitchens myself, I am unable to agree with extra. You rarely see a chef, sous chef, or line prepare dinner, fidgeting with something but a chef’s knife.

For this information, we centered on Chef’s knives for the explanations above; however, we additionally ran by dozens of paring, boning, utility, and bread knives to suggest certainly one of every of these as effectively. 

The perfect chef’s knife total

The 5 best kitchen knives we tested

Hefty, however, balanced, The standard German design of Wüsthof’s Classic Ikon 8″ Chef’s Knife fits most palms and stands as much as nearly each kitchen process.

  • Size: 6″, 8″, 10″
  • Blade: Excessive-carbon stainless-steel
  • HRC: 58
  • Deal with: Polyoxymethylene (POM)

Professionals: Nice for chopping and dicing, agreeable deal with for many, rust- and chip-resistant

Cons: Requires standard sharpening

The Wüsthof Classic Ikon Chef’s Knife is essentially the most conventional western knife there may be: It is large, it is heavy, and it is made with comparatively mushy, rust-, and chip-resistant stainless-steel. 

So far as high-quality knives go, that is the knife we have discovered to deal with essentially the most challenging duties, whereas additionally nonetheless providing agility and precision.

Earlier than we go additional, we should always point out one caveat: Forward of investing in a chef’s knife, know that of all of the kitchen knives you would possibly buy, it’s the most private alternative you are going to must make.

Irrespective of which knife you select, your Chef’s knife is the one you rely on most. It provides the most floor space for bigger chopping essentially and slicing jobs, and it additionally handles the most drive for hardier root greens, meat, and poultry essentially. Completely different designs would favor chopping and dice over slicing (and vice-versa); however, we like the one barely rounded stomach of the Wüsthof Classic Ikon, which strikes a cheerful medium for the two duties.

We additionally just like the modified deal with of the Ikon sequence knives basically, which is not reasonably German, however not reasonably Japanese, both. It appears to be a hybrid of the two and comfortably matches most palms (we positioned our prime choice in many completely different palms).

All in all, it is an excellent knife for the joint family by which kitchen knives aren’t typically taken care of, and irrespective of who will get a maintain of this factor or what they do with or to it, you’ll carry it again as much as snuff. That and the truth that it is a comparatively skinny and agile blade so far as German knives make it the perfect all-around choice based primarily on our testing.

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

The perfect price range chef’s knife

The 5 best kitchen knives we tested

Well-liked in busy industrial kitchens and houses alike, Victorinox’s Fibrox has an exceptionally ergonomic deal with and stands as much as rugged use like few others.

  • Size: 7.9″
  • Blade: Excessive-carbon stainless-steel
  • HRC: 55
  • Deal with: Thermoplastic elastomers (TPE)

Professionals: Maneuverable, snug deal with, first-rate edge retention

Cons: Not razor-sharp straight out of the manufacturing unit, takes some work to sharpen, not completely balanced 

Victorinox’s whole Fibrox line is a favorite in industrial kitchens. As a result of its knives are among the many few that may move by quite a few line cooks’ palms and unintentional journeys by the dishwasher unscathed. The Fibrox Chef’s Knife is budget-friendly; nevertheless, it’s additionally suitable for short-term leases, first residences, and extra typically, individuals who do not essentially need to spend time caring for their kitchen instruments. 

My kitchen sees lots of “cooks,” and for that purpose, I’ve my knives squirreled away individually from the communal kitchen knives that are totally from Victorinox. In this fashion, I haven’t got to fret about somebody slicing a lemon and leaving a costly knife on the counter, not solely moist however coated in citric acid, or attempting to pry open a lid by way of a Japanese blade, which is horrific to consider. 

And even though the Fibrox Chef’s Knife has withstood the abuse talked about above (and extra), there’s neither a single stain nor chip on it. Positive, it is a bit scratched (coarse sponges are horrible for chrome steel, however extra on care below); however, primarily though all I do is give it a sharpening each couple of months, which with diligence will get it sharper than it was from the manufacturing unit, and it performs impressively.

We also discover it to be just a little on the safer facet due to the ultra-grippy Fibrox deal, which is straightforward to carry even when moist or greasy.

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

The perfect paring knife

The 5 best kitchen knives we tested

A paring knife is an easy instrument for lighter duties, and Victorinox’s 3.25″ Straight Paring Knife provides all the things you want of it and nothing you do not.

  • Size: 3.25″
  • Blade: 440 stainless-steel
  • HRC: 58-60
  • Deal with: Thermoplastic elastomers (TPE)

Professionals: Resilient, comparatively rust-proof, dishwasher-safe

Cons: Very light-weight, requires standard sharpening

You need not lay a fortune on a paring knife. We predict Victorinox’s 3.25″ Straight Paring Knife does the job about in addition to something as a result of it is not the blade you are going to depend on for heavier-duty duties.  

Hulling strawberries, slicing a tiny little bit of garlic, and peeling and seeding fruit is about all you will use it for. In contrast, they don’t seem to be essentially the most demanding duties; this knife handles them each bit in addition to what you’d hope something would. Positive, you may spend much more and get a weightier paring knife; nevertheless, it’s removed from essential.

And whereas, once more, it is about as low cost as any kitchen knife will get, it is also far more resilient than pricier picks. Years ago, indeed, one of our testers admitted to operating it by the dishwasher usually and has discovered just one speck of rust since. 

The one different challenge that arises with this knife is that you will have to sharpen it as usually as our price range chooses for a chef’s knife. Relying upon how typically you set it to work, that might vary from each month to every few months. 

In any other case, hold this knife clear and dry like some other, and it’ll work and final like some other.

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

The perfect bread knife

The 5 best kitchen knives we tested

A long, skinny blade with shallow serrations makes the surprisingly inexpensive Victorinox Fibrox 10″ Bread Knife an exact instrument for slicing bread and extra.

  • Size: 10.25″
  • Blade: 440 stainless-steel
  • HRC: 55
  • Deal with: Thermoplastic elastomers (TPE)

Professionals: Properly weighted (for a budget-friendly knife), excellent grip

Cons: Not as heavy as top-of-the-line bread knives, not as sharp out of the manufacturing unit

Whether or not you need to spend a lot on a bread knife, relying on how typically you may be utilizing it; however, Victorinox’s Fibrox Bread Knife is a high-quality instrument at an inexpensive cost. It withstands the identical quantity of rugged use as the remainder of our suggestions from that line. However, the bigger deal with and longer blade carries just a little extra weight than the additional budget-friendly choices we thought of. 

In our exams, which concerned slicing less-than-forgiving, homemade, no-knead bread, it fared in addition to all the things we tried till we reached the $200 vary, which is an absurd worth for a bread knife for most individuals. That just about settled it. 

We can also lend sufficient reward to the Fibrox handles, which everybody appears to understand. Other than their ergonomic qualities, they instill a way of safety with their non-slip grips.

As a result, this blade shouldn’t be solely skinny but also solely shallowly serrated; you will not have as much hassle sharpening it by yourself as you’d with, say, a deep-scalloped one that does not take to an easy pull-through sharpener as effectively. It additionally seems that this knife is not unhealthy for slicing softer fruits and carving meat and poultry.

Should you’re in search of one thing just a little extra on the inexpensive facet, our earlier choice (which we retested towards this one) is the Mercer Culinary Millennia Wavy Edge 10-inch Wide Bread Knife. It has a barely thicker blade and a deeper serration, so it will not be as exact; nevertheless, it’s bought an analogous deal with and prices half the worth.

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

The perfect utility knife

The 5 best kitchen knives we tested

With VG Max metal wrapped in layered Damascus metal, Shun’s Classic 6″ Utility Knife is sharper and retains a more significant edge than most German-style knives, and is ideal for trimming and exact extra cuts.

  • Size: 6″
  • Blade: VG-Max Damascus metal
  • HRC: 62
  • Deal with: Pakka (plastic and wood composite)

Professionals: Extraordinarily sharp, excellent edge retention, rust-resistant, very well-balanced

Cons: Barely brittle and simpler to chip than German metal, trim, D-shaped deal with favors right-handers

A utility knife must be further sharp for exact extra cuts and trimming without tearing meals. Shun’s Classic 6″ Utility Knife makes use of VG-Max Damascus metal, successfully providing the perfect of each world between Japanese-style and German-style blades.

Damascus metal is made by forging and hammering carbon-rich metal (in this case, VG-Max) at a low temperature, cranking up the warmth, then cooling it abruptly. The fabric is thought to be flexible and corrosion-resistant, not to mention its signature swirly “damask” sample that tends to woo every person. Whereas its magnificence is one thing to behold, the vital takeaway is that you get a knife that holds a more substantial edge than carbon metal however flexes higher than stainless steel. 

Whereas we veered away from Japanese metal for our Chef’s knife prime choice and did not suggest a Damascus or VG Max metal choice due to the associated fee, a smaller utility knife from Shun makes that pricier metal extra inexpensive.

Other than being remarkably extra rust-resistant than different Japanese and Japanese-style knives we tried, this knife is not so brittle that we have had hassle with chipping or dinging. Nonetheless, you may need to hold it away from more laborious meals and surfaces, and particularly bones. The place this knife shines is with more minor, in-between duties the site a chef’s knife is overkill, and a paring knife is painfully laborious. Assume slicing tomatoes or dicing shallots. It is not an essential knife for everybody, however behind these two knives and a bread knife, it is the subsequent most vital one for many kitchens. On that observation, it did supply sufficient flexibility for me to not essentially fillet, however, pores and skin and trim boneless meat. 

Shun’s knives are made with a fabric generally known as Pakka wooden, which is known as a wood-and-plastic composite that appears a terrible lot like walnut. Purists would possibly cringe; nevertheless, it gives the impression without bringing alongside the fear of the deal with splitting.

Should you’re averse to proudly owning a Japanese knife for one purpose or one other (both the deal with or the additional care required), look to the utility knife model of our top-recommended Chef’s knife, the 6″ Wüsthof Ikon.

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

What else we examined

The 5 best kitchen knives we tested

Shun: Most likely the most well-liked Japanese knife within the U.S., Shun provides comparatively inexpensive V.G.- and Damascus-steel knives. Besides recommending the model’s utility knife, one of my favorite private knives is the 8″ Chef’s knife.

Korin: One other mid-range Japanese knife just like Shun, Korin is a favorite of Pat LaFrieda and Andrew Zimmern and is aggressive with Mac.

J.A. Henckels: One of many veritable classics in German knives, J.A. Henckels’ knives had been just a little thicker within the blade than our different picks; however, you actually cannot go flawed right here.

Dexter-Russell: Just like Victorinox’s Fibrox sequence, Dexter-Russell provides a line of equally iconic white-handled knives at a tremendous worth level, and which you may discover in industrial kitchens throughout. We found that the handles on the Fibrox knives are a lot grippier.

Mac: This firm makes an impressive chef’s knife, particularly for its worth. The one purpose we could not suggest this as a natural choice was its delicacy. By the hands of most individuals, this knife will not remain in excellent form for lengthy. If you take care of your knives, then again, we will not suggest it is sufficient.

Made In: Like many different DTC-brand knives, these are made with X50CrMoV15 metal and are a fantastic deal for their worth. Just like the others, they did not precisely wow us; however, we discovered nothing flawed with them, both. The rounded deal appears to work effectively with many palms.

Material: These knives are made with “high-carbon” metal; however, we would not name them high-quality. They have a hybrid deal that should be swimsuit most palms, so they’re straightforward enough to sharpen and completely serviceable knives.

Misen: Extra X50CrMoV15 metal and a fantastic deal for its worth. These are extraordinarily in style for a purpose, and we like them lots, too.

Our Place: One other DTC model making X50CrMoV15 metal blades, Our Place’s knives are greater than passable. We favored the hybrid deal with, however, not as a lot as others. If the deal with seems prefer it’ll swimsuit you, these are correctly designed and balanced knives.

Steelport Knife Co.: This can be a lot fancier, the carbon-steel choice for somebody who needs to spend money on a beautiful and impossibly sharp blade. We find it irresistible; however, we additionally acknowledge that it requires care. 

Our methodology

The 5 best kitchen knives we tested

We finely sliced tomatoes and onions with Chef’s knives, minced garlic, shallots with utility and paring knives, hulled strawberries with paring knives, and sliced hard-crusted no-knead bread with serrated slicing knives. We then dulled every blade by rapping them repeatedly on a glass reducing board (phrase to the sensible, by no means, use certainly one of these) and returned to every knife’s respective process to notice any dulling or chipping.

We additionally made positive to place every knife into as many alternative palms as attainable, starting from skilled cooks to hobbyists.

Lastly, we consulted a sequence of cooks, butchers, and metallurgists, together with Chef Shola Olunloyo of Studio Kitchen, Pat LaFrieda, and Michael J Tarkanian, a professor of metallurgy at MIT.

A phrase on Japanese knives

We took Japanese knives out of the operating for our prime Chef’s knife choice. Whereas they are a personal favorite, they’re notoriously tough to care for and subsequently not fitted to most kitchens. Merely put, if you’re beginning to spend money on your kitchen knives, we do not need to suggest a practical knife that can be misused.

“Excessive-carbon stainless-steel” is a little bit of a buzzword in response to the recognition of Japanese-style knives, which might attain notoriously sharper edges than their German-style counterparts. The delicacy of Japanese knives has to do with the hardness of the usual high-carbon stainless steel, which permits for a more delicate and sharper, however proportionally brittler edge.

Nonetheless, in the event you’re the kind of one who takes significantly excellent care of your instruments (and are not sharing a kitchen with somebody who will not), you may desire a Japanese knife. However, know that they require meticulous cleansing and drying, in addition to cautious storage, or they will find themselves with rusted and chipped blades.

Different concerns:

Edge retention: Our knife-testing course concerned slicing recent tomatoes and paying attention to the benefit of every Chef’s knife dealing with the duty. After ample knowledge, we took every Chef’s knife to a glass reducing board and ran it over the floor 200 instances. Some knives held their edge, others not a lot. We seemed on the edges after operating the blades and famous if there had been any seen adjustments. 

We then returned to the tomatoes, reducing just a few extra and seeing how much resistance we felt in contrast with the efficiency of the knives straight out of the packaging. Knives that held their edges handed on to additional rounds of consideration.

Alloy and the HRC (hardness score): We consulted several specialists within the area; however, the most informative supply we encountered was Michael J Tarkanian, a professor of metallurgy at MIT. Along with his assistance, we had been capable of minimizing by the advertising and marketing and the scientific terminology behind completely different alloys and what permits a knife to retain an edge.

We seemed for a hardness score of round 60 HRC, which provides excellent edge retention whereas nonetheless permitting for a fringe of round 15 levels (although as much as 20 levels, which is duller than 15, was nevertheless thought of ample).

Ergonomics: For a knife to work effectively, you’ve gotten to have the ability to maintain it comfortably in your hand. We requested several individuals to select up knives and determine which of them had been the best to grip; throughout the board, they went for those with heavier, rounded, virtually bulbous handles.

Steadiness: The load of the deal and the blade can also be considered essential. Pricier knives virtually all the time supply higher stability; as a result, the additional value goes into utilizing denser and sometimes extra fascinating supplies, like layered Damascus metal. 

A well-balanced knife with a perfect blade will minimize greens with minimal stress, like our prime choice from Wusthof. A not-so-well-balanced knife will take just a little drive to get began.

What we sit up for testing

We’re trying ahead to testing Santoku knives and extra Japanese Chef’s knives for our subsequent replacement. Whereas they’re superior in foolproof methods, they do not stand as much as the tough dealing with that they’re going to endure by the hands of the ordinary residence prepare dinner, so we’ll have separate picks coming quickly. Till then, we’re large followers of Shun, International, Korin, and MAC. Know that while you won’t sharpen them as a lot as softer-steeled German blades, they’re barely extra vulnerable to rust (attributable to greater carbon ranges) and chipping (attributable to their elevated hardness).

We’re additionally going to suggest a boning knife for many who have to trim and debone meat; however, in the meantime, Victorinox’s Fibrox Pro is an inexpensive choice, and the Wüsthof Classic Ikon is a pricier step up which we like to date.


How to decide on a knife

A crucial factor in a few knives, notably a chef’s knife, is how it matches your hand. As long as you spend no less than $50 on a chef’s knife, it is going to be sharp (and sharpenable) sufficient to get almost any job completed. Resolve what sort of deal you need first. German-style knives are typically extra molded to the palm with a pronounced butt finish, whereas Japanese-style blades are virtually uniformly cylindrical and smaller. Each design work for everybody; it simply will depend on the texture you favor and, to some extent, the way you maintain the knife.

The kind of metal you select needs to be based mainly on the type of care you are (realistically) going to provide your knife. Should you do not envision yourself sharpening and completely drying and storing your blade after each use, German stainless-steel (e.g., 440, 420) goes to be far more forgiving, although softer and faster to uninteresting.

If you are an instrument fanatic and know that you’re going to take excellent care of your knives and are also assured that they will not discover their manner into the flawed palms, carbon metal is a good choice because it is incredibly sharp. Know that it is prone to rust and chip extra simply.

In between, you’ve gotten VG-10 and VG-Max (proprietary to Shun, however, about the identical as VG-10), which have added alloys (tungsten, vanadium) that make them just a little extra stain-resistant and fewer brittle. They’re excellent for many who desire a Japanese-style knife without having to care so devoutly for it.

Then there’s Damascus metal, which is made by forging and hammering carbon-rich metal at a low temperature, cranking up the warmth, after which cooling it abruptly. Damascus metal is thought of for its flexibility and corrosion resistance, and we suggest it be cautious of too-good-to-be-true offers. Various producers will etch the mesmerizing swirls right into a blade without performing the time-consuming and costly hammering course.

Why (or why not) purchase a knife set.

Typically, issues available in units are likely to contain compromised high quality and sometimes include filler items. Within the case of knife units, you are in all probability going to obtain a bunch of knives and different devices (together with a big woodblock) that you could be by no means use. 

Various newer (and older) DTC manufacturers acknowledge that customers are rising wiser and studying that units are typically a ripoff. Because of this, there are many two- to five-piece units available on the market. Should you’re trying within the price range vary, we’re all for them, and we have just about tried all of them. The metal is nearly identical high quality, so select based mainly on the type you want.

In any other case, although, units do not make lots of sense for most individuals. Spend money on a chef’s knife, at the start, with which, by the best way, you can sort out your whole kitchen duties, minus possibly slicing bread. Subsequently, a paring knife might be the most innovative buy, and however, since it is not doing lots of the heavy work, we are saying go low cost. That mentioned, be happy to spend what you would like; there’s something to be mentioned for a weightier, sharper blade within the case of each knife.

A slicing and bread knife could or is probably not vital to you, relying upon whether or not or not you devour a lot of bread or slice a lot of meat. You’ll find one who does the job for as little as $20, or, once more, the sky is the restrict. For most individuals, we just like the $40-$60 vary.

Past the above, you are moving into particular duties most individuals do not tackle at residence. Fillet knives, boning knives, santoku knives, and shears are all additional concerns. Even if you’d like all of these knives, you are still possibly higher off buying them piecemeal. It’s going to be extra inexpensive, and you will additionally be capable of price range to put your cash the place it counts.


A diagram of a chef’s knife pointing out each feature.

Heal: The nook of the blade is the place the sting meets the bolster.

Edge: The sharpened, enterprise facet of the blade.

Tang: The a part of the blade that runs to or by the deal with. “Full-tang” is a typical period, suggesting the blade metal is a single piece that runs by the agreement.

Rivets: The pins holding the deal collectively (extra frequent in German handles).

Bolster: Above the heel, a spacer the place the blade meets the deal with, and a space to seize or choke upon when performing more acceptable duties.

Tip: The sharp or entrance finish of the knife reverse the deal with.

Excessive-carbon metal: Metal with no less than 0.55% carbon content material.

Stainless steel: An alloy of iron, chromium, and typically different metals. This can be a widespread period; nevertheless, it’s the fundamental metal German knives. They are made.

VG10, VG-Max: A high-carbon metal blended with tungsten and vanadium and typically different metals to lend flexibility and rust resistance.

Damascus Metal: A two-plus-millennia-old course of Damascus metal is made by forging and hammering carbon-rich metal at a low temperature, cranking up the warmth, then cooling it abruptly, repeatedly (typically dozens of instances). Damascus metal is thought for its flexibility and corrosion resistance, whereas nonetheless retaining a superior edge, which is why it’s historically (and famously) used for samurai swords.

You may also like

More articles

Disclosure: Written and researched by We spotlight services and products you would possibly find interestingWhen you purchase them, we might get a small share of the revenue from the sale from our companions. We might obtain merchandise freed from cost from producers to test. This doesn't drive our choice as as to if or not a product is featured or advisable. We function independently from our promoting workforce. We welcome your suggestions. E-mail us at [email protected].

When you buy through our links, we may earn some money from our affiliate partners. Learn more.

Latest article