The best indoor herb gardens we tested

The pandemic did greater than enhance our time spent on Zoom; folks’ interest in gardening also skyrocketed. The latest gardening increase was so pronounced that many seed suppliers sold out rapidly because of huge curiosity from non-commercial clients. Firms that promote indoor gardening kits have additionally seen a rise in demand, with many promoting inventory faster than they’ll change it. 

I have been a gardener for more than ten years, and my gardening pursuits, until not too long ago, have primarily been relegated to the outside. I will confess, I used to assume indoor gardening was a fad. However, in the early days of the pandemic, I felt compelled to put money into a rising indoor unit. 

I like and cherish my entrance yard backyard; however indoor gardens require little upkeep and let me develop spherically veggies. I’ve used my indoor backyard for two years now and might genuinely say it has completely modified my gardening expertise. 

For this information, I examined further indoor gardens over many months. I’ve planted, grown, pruned, and eaten an entire lot of crops to assist others in storing for their very personal indoor edible backyard. I additionally spoke with Dr. Deane Falcone, chief science officer of Crop One, a vertical farming firm, to achieve some skilled perception on indoor rising.

Our testing methodology

To test the gardens featured on this information, I used all of them for not less than a month — some for longer. Here are the factors I used when evaluating every unit.

  • Setup: I used to be searching for gardens that had been simple to arrange and use. Was the setup sophisticated? Wouldn’t it be easy for somebody new to gardening? 
  • Efficiency: It is powerful to gauge progress price amongst gardens as a result of there are such a lot of variables concerned, so I used to be extra involved about whether or not taking good care of the backyard was intuitive. Additionally, if a backyard produced constant progress failures, it would not cross the test. 
  • Particular options: The great thing about indoor gardening models is that they’ll characteristic quite a lot of cool tech that is unattainable to make use of outdoors. When testing the gardens, I used to discover if any good options had been simple to use and whether they added any worth to the product.

One of the best indoor backyard general

The best indoor herb gardens we tested

The Rise Triple Family Garden is a well-designed hydroponic system for these missing outside the rising houses. It is equally helpful for keen gardeners seeking to increase and develop out of season.

  • Capability: 36 crops, extra with add-ons
  • Pricing: $549 for a single-tier unit, $749 for the two-tier, and $949 for the three-tier
  • Alternative pods: 4-pack for $9.99, $12.49 for 4-pack of “Reserve” pods
  • Most significant for Individuals who haven’t got the house for an outside backyard and those that need a regular provide of homegrown meals 12 months out of the yr

Professionals: Excessive capability design, computerized lighting, water sensors, and a companion app that reminds you when to carry out duties like including vitamins and harvesting

Cons: Some technical hiccups right here and there, “Reserve” alternative pods are overpriced

Firstly, I bought the Rise Family Garden of the pandemic and have been utilizing it for over a yr now. It is developing into a dialog piece and an integral part of my kitchen. Proper now, as my outside backyard struggles within the warmth, the Rise is producing picture-perfect produce. 

The three-tier household backyard (it is accessible in one, two, or three-tier choices) comes with trays that let you develop as many as 36 crops. You should buy add-on trays to extend that yield to 108 crops. The underside tier is the tallest and perfect for rising crops like tomatoes or peppers. The opposite two cabinets are shorter and ideal for increasing issues like child kale, lettuce, herbs, and beets. 

Every unit comes with a starter pack of vitamins and a few seed pods to get you began. As soon as it is assembled, you simply fill the reservoir and plug it in. The backyard’s water pump helps flow into the water all through the unit. You will want to attach the backyard to Wi-Fi to reap the benefits of all its good options like water reminders, computerized plant care, and distant mild management. 

I’ve beloved each minute of rising with the Rise. My unit has nearly changed my outside backyard at this level. There have been some technical hiccups right here and there — like flickering lights or connectivity issues — however, customer support has been fast to reply and assist me after I run into points. 

The unit does require standard upkeep; however, it’s far lower than what I usually need to do outside. Issues like watering, including vitamins, and cleaning every 6 months aren’t too time-consuming. 

A hydroponic backyard just like the Rise won’t utterly change an outside rising house — there’s not sufficient room to develop potatoes, for instance, which develop underground — however, it’s a formidable various. Primarily based on my expertise as a gardener, produce grows significantly sooner within the Rise than outside. And the whole lot is simply as tasty, too.

One of the best compact indoor backyard

The best indoor herb gardens we tested

The Rise Personal Garden is a countertop hydroponic system excellent for these dwelling in tight quarters.

  • Capability: eight crops, extra with add-ons
  • Pricing: $279
  • Alternative pods: 4-pack for $9.99, $12.49 for 4-pack of “Reserve” plant pods
  • Most significant for: Individuals quick on the house who nonetheless wish to get pleasure from the advantages of an indoor backyard

Professionals: Compact, engaging, and has all of the good options of its larger-sized sibling

Cons: Intermittent water pump points

The Personal Garden is a miniaturized model of the family-sized unit — measuring solely 18 inches in width. It is sensible for individuals who aren’t prepared to sacrifice ground house but have some counter room to spare. Due to its smaller footprint, it additionally requires fewer water refills than the enormous backyard and is less complicated to scrub.

Regardless of its smaller dimension, the mini backyard continues to be a potent plant producer. You may develop as many as 12 crops; however, the tray that comes with the unit holds eight. The Personal Garden has a small window at its base to let you understand when the water degree is low — as an alternative to the LED indicator on the larger unit. 

Moreover, when the built-in water sensor detects that there is not sufficient water, a blue mild on the high of the unit will flash to provide you with a warning that it is time to refill. I’ve had some hassle with this characteristic — the sunshine will flash when there’s nonetheless loads of water left — however, customer support has been responsive and valuable. They’re currently sending me a brand new water pump to see if that solves the difficulty. 

In the end, the minor technical glitches have not soured my Rise hydroponic gardening expertise. I always want to test on my backyard, replant seeds, and admire the colorful, usually aromatic crops in my kitchen. As soon as crops are sufficiently big, you possibly can anticipate reaping good lettuce to make salads several instances per week or loads of herbs to add to sauces or use as garnish each couple of days.

One of the best indoor herb backyard

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

An ultra-compact, low-maintenance countertop backyard that is perfect for rising herbs and child greens.

  • Capability: 6 crops
  • Pricing: $179
  • Alternative pods: accessible in numerous bundles, the six pod kits are $15.95
  • Most excellent for: Rising herbs without taking on an excessive amount of actual countertop property

Professionals: Takes up minimal counter house, very easy to make use of

Cons: Plant spacing is tight, and the built-in lighting feels hotter than different plant lights I’ve used

This smooth tiny backyard is ideal for rising kitchen herbs. Most individuals who dream of getting recent basil or parsley readily available regularly make the error of losing cash on small potted grocery retailer herbs. It is a query that I get requested regularly: “how do I develop herbs in my kitchen?” 

The reply: a small hydroponic unit like this one from Aerogarden will give you a steady provide of herbs when you plan issues properly. Whereas Aerogarden sells plant pods for tomatoes and peppers, these crops are in all probability higher suited to bigger models. The compact Harvest Elite’s spacing is just too tight for a bountiful harvest from fruit-bearing crops.

It has been a breeze to keep up within the month or so that I have been utilizing the Aerogarden. The unit jogs my memory to pop in a cap-full of vitamins and add water at times, and the lights activate and off mechanically. Periodically, the sunshine peak must be adjusted to accommodate the rising crops. 

My sole grievance is that the LED develops mild is surprisingly heat to the contact. I have not had any points, but I fear that potential plant burn should I overlook to boost the peak of the affixed mild sooner or later.

What we’re testing subsequent

I am already within the strategy of testing just a few different indoor backyard methods. Here is what’s up subsequent:

Pros and cons of indoor gardening

Pros: Consistency in rising circumstances

One vital benefit of indoor gardening, says Dr. Falcone, is the flexibility to manage almost all variables. With an indoor backyard, you management the climate. Situations are typically much more constant inside than they’re outdoors. 

Pros: Extra tender, uniform produce

Vegetation has it good indoors and, in flip, produce is much more uniform. As a result of crops do not need to react to altering circumstances, they are typically extra tender and delicate than those grown outdoors, which may typically find yourself fibrous and difficult, stated Dr. Falcone. Opposite to widespread perception, meals grown hydroponically can style extra flavorful than produce grown outdoors since you will have a lot of extra management over the rising circumstances.

Pros: Fewer pests

You additionally haven’t got to fret about pests to the identical diploma, he provides. Insect infestations can nonetheless occur, however they are much simpler to manage. My Rise Household Backyard has infested with fungus gnats earlier this yr as a result of I introduced it in an of doors plant without considering, however completely cleansing it out with vinegar stopped the issue in its tracks. 

Con: Creating constant produce requires planning

Whereas indoor gardening is simple, it nonetheless requires some planning as a daily outside backyard does. “You plant the whole lot directly. Guess what? You get to reap the whole lot directly,” says Dr. Falcone. Succession planting — planting crops in staggered intervals — ensures that you’re going to all the time have one thing recent readily available. In fact, this implies your indoor backyard will not look as full and vibrant. 

Con: Feels much less like “gardening”

Whilst somebody whose job includes indoor hydroponics, Dr. Falcone additionally concedes that there is nothing that may change the aesthetic of outside gardening. Desirous to be outdoors and work together with nature is an enormous part of why he and his spouse nonetheless backyard outside. 

Con: Restricted house

Whereas indoor produce will develop large when you let it, you are usually restricted when it comes to the house. Tomato crops cannot develop as tall as they might outside, for example. You are in the end constrained to the scale of the backyard you are rising in.

What to search for in an indoor backyard

a close up photo of the illuminated buttons on an indoor garden as part of testing for the best indoor gardens in 2021
Steph Coelho/Insider


Dr. Falcone recommends utilizing a develop mild on a timer when gardening indoors. Fortunately, most high-quality good indoor gardens have the lighting mechanically set for the consumer. Moreover, gardens with LED development lights are a sensible choice as a result of they’re cool to the contact and require much less vitality. 

Vegetation grown with loads of mild does not simply develop sooner, they give the impression of being sturdier and less lanky than those grown with speckled mild. Firms that promote windowsill gardens and recommend you depend on daylight are, frankly, stuffed with BS. If you cannot backyard outdoors in full solar, LED lights are the subsequent neatest thing.

Ease of use and house 

I like to recommend searching for an indoor backyard that has sufficient house for what you intend to develop. In order for you, a gradual provide of greens to feed a household of 4, go along with a full-sized unit, which is concerning the dimension of a bookcase. In the event, you simply need recent herbs every so often so as to add to your recipes, go for a smaller countertop backyard. No matter what you select, it ought to suit your house in each aesthetic and dimension. 

An indoor backyard also needs to be simple to make use of and clear. If it is not, you may end up neglecting it. Identical to a well-designed outside backyard is a pleasure to domesticate, a nicely-thought-out indoor backyard is extra prone to develop into a routinely used family fixture.

Hydroponic vs. soil-based methods

A hydroponic backyard is soilless. Plant roots sit in and get their vitamins immediately from the water. Against this, in a soil-based backyard, the roots cannot develop previous the soil pods and ultimately develop into root-bound. 

In my expertise, hydroponic models have a tendency to supply crops with extra life than models with soil-based pods. Herbs grown in a hydroponic system will final months and months so long as you proceed to read them. Minimize-and-come once more crops, like lettuce, will even proceed to supply till they ship out a flower stalk — at which era they develop into bitter. 

And until you are searching for an enjoyable indoor rising undertaking to do with children, keep away from potted herb kits. The crops are by no means final lengthy, they usually are an ache to maintain alive.

Sensible options

Sensible options aren’t a should, however, they’re mighty handy. Monitoring progress in an app and receiving reminders to water or add vitamins is useful for people who find themselves new to gardening (or scatterbrained).  

Search for options like water sensors, computerized nutrient reminders, and harvest monitoring. They will make your life simpler. The Rise app, for instance, even alerts you when it is time to harvest crops. Generally, the timing is a bit off, however, the alert continues to be a reminder to not let meals go to waste.


Would I like to attach my indoor hydroponic backyard to my dwelling’s plumbing?

No. Most all-in-one hydroponic gardens have a water tank and a pump that circulates water and vitamins. When the water degree is low, you refill the tank with water out of your faucet.

Can I develop root crops indoors?

Technically it is attainable, however, it’ll require experimentation and the produce in all probability will not look very fairly. You are higher off sticking with crops that primarily develop above the floor.

Does my water’s high quality matter?

As a newbie, you in all probability needn’t fear an excessive amount of concerning the water high quality. “If it is ok for people to drink, it is actually ok to develop crops,” stated Dr. Falcone.

Nonetheless, superior growers might wish to use filtered water. Water high quality can impression the pH of your system, which, in flip, can mess with nutrient uptake. This may have an effect on plant progress and trigger issues like leaf yellowing. 

If you wish to get much more exact, you possibly can hold tabs on pH with a meter (5.5 to six.5 is an effective vary to shoot for with hydroponic rising). You may add the pH-lowering product to a hydroponic backyard to make changes. 

Our top-rated backyard additionally comes with equipment for calibrating your water pH, and the app makes it extraordinarily simple and consumer-pleasant.

In addition to greens, what else can I develop in my indoor backyard?

You may develop some fruits. Strawberries, for instance, develop nicely indoors, as do self-pollinating crops like tomatoes and peppers. For cucumbers and squash, you may have to do the work usually done by bees and other efficient insects. You should utilize a paintbrush or your finger to softly “tickle” the flowers to pollinate them, however an instrument just like the Bee the Bee Pollinator makes it extra enjoyable. 

Moreover, many indoor gardeners experiment with rising flowers. When you’ve got a house beneath the lights, it’s also possible to give light-starved houseplants some love.

How do I keep away from pests like fungus gnats?

Wrapping plant pods in foil (and poking holes to accommodate sprouting crops) virtually wholly eliminates algae progress which is a big attractant for sure pests like fungus gnats.

Do I’ve to make use of the vitamins or seed pods bought by an organization?

Nope! Seed packets are available at {hardware} shops, nurseries, and online. And hydroponic pods are simple to search out at online retailers like Amazon.

For plant meals, Dr. Falcone recommends utilizing a complete mixture with a balanced ratio of NPK (Nitrogen, Phosphorus, and Potassium). 

You may also like


Latest articles


PROS Active noise cancellation is even better.Sound is more balanced...

Mobile Pixels Duex Lite Review

The Mobile Pixels Duex Lite ($269) differs from most...

Payoneer Review

Payoneer is a financial services firm based in New...

The Jabra Elite 7 Pro

The Elite 85t earphones from Jabra pleased us with...

Disclosure: Written and researched by the Get Gear Tech crew. We spotlight services and products you may discover fascinating. If you happen to purchase them, we could get a small share of the income from the sale from our companions. We could obtain merchandise freed from cost from producers to test. This doesn't drive our resolution as to whether a product is featured or beneficial. We function independently from our promoting group. We welcome your suggestions. Please e-mail us at [email protected] 

Get Gear Tech is an affiliate-based website that tests and reviews the best tech, appliances, gear, and more. You can trust our veteran reviewers and experts to find the best stuff just for you. Get Gear Tech strives to be probably the most trusted product suggestion and service on the web. We obsessively test and report on thousands of things annually to suggest one of the best of all the things. We aim to save lots of you time and get rid of the stress of buying, whether or not you’re on the lookout for on a regular basis gear or items for family members. We work with complete editorial independence. Meaning nothing seems on the location as a suggestion until our writers and editors have deemed it one of the best by our rigorous reporting and testing.


find out more!